Editorial policy · October 21, 2026
Every category needs its own evidence.
A purifier score is not comparable with a humidifier, a standalone HVAC filter or an installed air-cleaner cabinet score. AirScore measures performance and ownership costs only where credible, model-specific evidence is available.
← Compare air and humidity products
Ground rules before scoring
- Exact brand/model/variant and category, source URL, source date and availability are recorded first.
- Only values actually provided by that product's manufacturer or independently verifiable test source earn points. A manufacturer claim is not an independent certification.
- Every Research Index uses a 100-point category rubric. Missing criteria earn zero points; their weights are never redistributed, averaged or filled with invented measurements.
- Appliances below the coverage threshold or missing required inputs receive a clearly labelled provisional score. The underlying Research Index includes the missing-data penalty before public calibration; evidence coverage is shown separately. A low or zero provisional score may reflect missing documentation, not poor measured performance.
- For example, a purifier with 42 research points and 70% evidence coverage displays a category-relative 56/100 using the fixed 71-point purifier reference. The missing criteria still earn zero research points; coverage remains 70%, and qualification remains provisional if the required inputs or threshold are unmet. The scale does not redistribute missing weights or subtract a penalty twice.
- Equipment fit, compatible filter depth and airflow remain separate requirements. HVAC replacement filters retain a household-specific FilterScore and require confirmed compatibility; a generic score cannot establish fit.
- Missing installed quotations earn zero points in the installed-price criterion. Equipment-only prices are never substituted, and installation costs are never estimated.
- Affiliate commission, sponsorship and merchant availability do not alter scores. Original and compatible-filter brands use the same objective criteria.
- Discontinued units remain excluded from purchasable rankings, even when third-party listings still exist.
A consistent review scale out of 100
Public appliance scores are category-relative editorial indices. A fixed reference based on the October 21 catalog maps the leading documented total in each comparable category to 95/100. Zero research points remain zero. Below the reference, public score = round(95 × Research Index ÷ reference). Above it, the remaining research range maps linearly from 95 to 100. This preserves order, including missing-data penalties, and leaves room for improvement. The same model uses the same reference on every page; a filtered shortlist cannot change its score.
A provisional category leader can receive 95 while important evidence is missing. That means it leads this documented comparison, not that its performance is 95% proven. Always read the evidence coverage, underlying Research Index, required fit and source limitations. A score is not percent removal, certification, a safety probability or a universal recommendation.
- purifier: 71 research points → 95/100
- humidifier: 92 research points → 95/100
- dehumidifier: 49 research points → 95/100
- hybrid: 60 research points → 95/100
- whole-home-air-cleaner: 75 research points → 95/100
- humidifier:whole-home: 32 research points → 95/100
- dehumidifier:whole-home: 79 research points → 95/100
- dehumidifier:professional: 60 research points → 95/100
Evidence thresholds and category weights below are unchanged. The versioned references remain fixed when a source is missing or a shopper filters the catalog; a future reference revision must be disclosed and applied consistently.
Room air purifiers — AirScore · Purifier
Evidence qualification requires 85% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: smokeCadrCfm, priceUsd. Otherwise, the appliance receives a provisional total with zero points for each missing criterion.
- 35% — Published smoke CADR. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Smoke CADR per operating watt. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Max-fan noise. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Annual replacement media cost. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Manufacturer device price. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Base warranty. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
Whole-home HVAC air cleaners — CabinetScore · Installed HVAC media air cleaner
Evidence qualification requires 85% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: merv, includedMediaVerified, pressureDrop500FpmInWg. Otherwise, the appliance receives a provisional total with zero points for each missing criterion.
- 25% — Published media MERV rating. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 25% — Measured static pressure drop at 500 FPM (in. w.g.). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Exact bundled replacement media identified. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Conservative manufacturer service interval (months). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Published cabinet warranty (years). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Published accessible filter servicing. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Published maximum airflow, not design target (CFM). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
Humidifiers — HumidityScore · Humidifier
Evidence qualification requires 85% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: outputMlPerHour, priceUsd. Otherwise, the appliance receives a provisional total with zero points for each missing criterion.
- 25% — Published moisture output (mL/h). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Published coverage. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Automatic humidity control. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Access for routine cleaning. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Water reservoir size. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Device price. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Base warranty. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Manufacturer-stated maximum runtime. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
Dehumidifiers — HumidityScore · Portable dehumidifier
Evidence qualification requires 85% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: pintsPerDay, iefLitersKwh. Otherwise, the appliance receives a provisional total with zero points for each missing criterion.
- 30% — Moisture removal at disclosed test conditions. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 25% — DOE integrated energy factor (L/kWh). We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Automatic humidistat. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Continuous drainage. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Cold-temperature operation. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Warranty. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Equipment price, excluding installation. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
Purifier + humidifier — Air + HumidityScore
Evidence qualification requires 90% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: smokeCadrCfm, outputMlPerHour. Otherwise, the appliance receives a provisional total with zero points for each missing criterion.
- 30% — Published smoke CADR. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 30% — Published moisture output. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Humidity setpoint control. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 10% — Annual replacement cost. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Device price. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Warranty. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
HVAC filters — FilterScore · Household-specific
Evidence qualification requires 85% of total weighted inputs and these source-confirmed dimensions: ratingFit, annualReplacementUsd, confirmedCabinetFit, pressureDropInWg. FilterScore also requires confirmed household and equipment fit.
- 30% — Household filtration need fit. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 30% — Annual replacement cost. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 20% — Exact approved filter fit. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
- 15% — Published pressure drop. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Lower verified values earn higher component points.
- 5% — Replacement interval. We normalize the verified measurement within the disclosed comparison range and apply the category weight. Higher verified values earn higher component points.
HumidityScore · Whole-home humidifier
Separate rubric for humidifier:whole-home. Evidence qualification requires 90% coverage and these inputs: outputGalDayAtKnownConfig, installedQuoteUsd, annualMaintenanceUsd. Incomplete scores are provisional. Missing installed quotations earn zero points; equipment prices are not substituted.
- 30% — Output at declared voltage/current (gallons/day)
- 15% — Documented electrical operating cost per season
- 15% — Automatic indoor/outdoor humidity management
- 15% — Annual consumables/service cost
- 20% — Installed owner quotation
- 5% — Warranty
HumidityScore · Whole-home dehumidifier
Separate rubric for dehumidifier:whole-home. Evidence qualification requires 90% coverage and these inputs: pintsPerDay, efficiencyPintsKwh, installedQuoteUsd, testConditionsVerified. Incomplete scores are provisional. Missing installed quotations earn zero points; equipment prices are not substituted.
- 25% — Moisture removal at documented test conditions
- 25% — Documented energy efficiency at comparable conditions
- 10% — Cold-weather operation
- 10% — Automatic humidistat
- 10% — Drain/duct installation options
- 15% — Installed owner quotation
- 5% — Warranty
HumidityScore · Professional dehumidifier
Separate rubric for dehumidifier:professional. Evidence qualification requires 90% coverage and these inputs: pintsPerDay, efficiencyPintsKwh, testConditionsVerified, installedQuoteUsd. Incomplete scores are provisional. Missing installed quotations earn zero points; equipment prices are not substituted.
- 30% — Moisture removal at 80 °F / 60% RH
- 25% — Energy efficiency at 80 °F / 60% RH
- 10% — Operating temperature minimum
- 10% — Continuous drain
- 10% — Automatic humidistat
- 10% — Installed owner quotation
- 5% — Warranty
Additional compatibility and category exclusions
HVAC/MERV: Compare household needs first (everyday dust, pets, allergies, smoke, older equipment or maximum filtration). Next filter by exact nominal and actual size, physical depth, documented blower/cabinet MERV limit, replacement spend and pressure drop at the stated airflow. MERV 13 and higher are not automatically best; EPA recommends MERV 13 or the highest rated filter the system can accommodate.
Purifier room sizing: When a shopper supplies room area, compare verified smoke CADR against AHAM’s general two-thirds-of-area guidance. For wildfire smoke, AHAM advises a smoke CADR approximately equal to the room's square footage at eight-foot ceilings; taller ceilings need more clean-air delivery. This is a separate fit indicator, not a certification or a hidden component of the product's overall score. Products reporting only unlabeled CADR or advertised coverage stay marked as unverified for this comparison. AHAM room-sizing reference.
Room purifiers: Compare smoke CADR (for fine-particle cleaning), wattage/efficiency, replacement cost, noise and price. Manufacturer statements such as "large room" without CADR are not treated as interchangeable with independent CADR.
Whole-home installed air cleaners: CabinetScore is specific to a complete HVAC cabinet with an exact included filter SKU. Compare published MERV, static pressure drop at the same 500-FPM face velocity, identifiable replacement media, conservative media life, service access, warranty and published maximum airflow. Missing comparable pressure-drop evidence earns zero points and keeps the score provisional. A higher cabinet maximum flow does not establish safe airflow through a particular home. Installer quotes and system-specific static pressure are not part of the standardized cabinet score; professionally verify fit and operating conditions.
Humidifiers: Compare documented moisture output, area, cleaning design, controls, tank size, runtime, price and warranty. Portable and standalone console scores may use documented manufacturer maximum output, with the operating mode and any US-unit conversion disclosed. These ratings are not independent measurements at matched room temperature and humidity; actual evaporation varies with conditions. We do not infer output or runtime by dividing reservoir size by the other value. Mineral-aerosol concerns for ultrasonic units must be explained; a humidifier is not a purifier merely because it has a dust screen.
Portable dehumidifier efficiency: Where there is an exact matching ENERGY STAR certificate, FilterTier uses the DOE Integrated Energy Factor (IEF) in liters of water removed per kilowatt-hour. It is not the same as a manufacturer's pints/kWh at a single 80°F/60%RH test point, and the two values are never automatically mixed or converted into the same ranking. Even among certified appliances, IEF is only one of several scoring criteria. Older model variants and differently suffixed pump/no-pump products must be verified separately. ENERGY STAR test methodology ↗
Dehumidifiers: Whole-home/crawlspace dealer equipment is scored separately from portable room dehumidifiers; extraction capacity must be compared at matching temperature/humidity conditions. Non-comparable pint figures are disclosed, not treated as identical.
Rechecking prices, claims and photos
Source pages and asset ownership belong to the relevant manufacturer. Prices are captured with a date and treated as observations. An unverified price appears as “Price not verified”. Source images are linked by manufacturer URLs with visible fallbacks; failure to load a photo never silently swaps in a different model.
Where the official link points to a category page, seller or PDF rather than the exact product, that must be noted. Review links and product status before recommending any checkout action.
Background references: EPA MERV guidance · EPA guide to air cleaners · ENERGY STAR room air cleaners.