TRANSPARENT METHODOLOGY

Brands don't get to define the score.

This page explains whole-home water-system scoring and the ZIP water report. Under-sink RO has its own methodology, and each air comparison explains its selection criteria. Exact-model evidence, useful specifications and ownership tradeoffs guide our research. Unknown data stays unknown.

WaterScore: a review index out of 100.

The nine published weights produce a Research Index out of 100. For whole-home water systems, the public WaterScore is round(95 × Research Index ÷ 84) at or below 84 research points; above 84 it is round(95 + 5 × (Research Index − 84) ÷ 16). Zero remains zero, 84 maps to 95, and 100 maps to 100. This fixed reference keeps leading reviewed systems near 95 without changing evidence, treatment or ownership inputs. The same model has the same score on every list. Evidence scores remain separate. WaterScore is not a removal percentage, certification or safety probability. RO and AIR use their own disclosed category formulas. Missing evidence earns zero credit at its original weight; those weights are not redistributed.

20%20%15%10%10%10%5%5%5%

20%

Contaminant reduction

Breadth and meaningful reduction of contaminants the exact system is designed to address.

20%

Certification & evidence

Certified systems score differently from independent tests, manufacturer tests and unsupported claims.

15%

Flow & sizing

Service/certified flow, peak flow, pressure considerations and bundle bottlenecks.

10%

10-year cost

Equipment plus scheduled media, cartridges, salt, UV and stated service assumptions.

10%

Maintenance

Frequency, complexity, homeowner effort and required professional service.

10%

Treatment capability

Filtration, true softening, conditioning, UV and specialty treatment fit.

5%

Warranty

Actual component coverage rather than headline marketing.

5%

Installation

Plumbing size, drain, electricity, bypass and installation complexity.

5%

Transparency

Quality and accessibility of manuals, performance data and replacement information.

“Removes PFAS” is not a complete sentence.

Four evidence levels, from claim to certification.

LEVEL 1

Certified

Exact system independently certified for the specified contaminant reduction claim.

LEVEL 2

Independent lab tested

Third-party test data is available, but the complete system is not certified for that claim.

LEVEL 3

Manufacturer tested

Published manufacturer testing supports the exact claim.

LEVEL 4

Claim only

Marketing claim found; supporting exact-model test evidence has not been verified.

Component certification is labeled separately.

A certified housing, carbon media or valve does not automatically prove the complete system meets the claim.