Whole-house air cleaners are installed in an HVAC duct/return-air path. They are different from portable room purifiers: without a compatible blower and cabinet installation, a MERV rating alone does not tell you how much air gets cleaned.
Compare five specific complete cabinets: passive MERV 11 and MERV 13 media options plus the powered AprilAire 5000 with Model 501 MERV 10 media. Each choice identifies its exact replacement media, application size, source-backed specifications and CabinetScore evidence status. The list follows CabinetScore from highest to lowest, with tied models separated by installation size. Provisional scores retain their evidence warnings; this order does not establish head-to-head laboratory superiority or compatibility with your HVAC system.
The numbered picks identify installation situations—not a claim that one cabinet performs best in every house. The separate CabinetScore (0–100) includes zero points for missing criteria; incomplete totals are labelled provisional. A score never certifies your existing blower, cabinet opening or ductwork.
EDITORIAL PICK #1 · 20 × 25 return-duct cabinet
Honeywell Home F200F2025/U · 20 × 25 Media Air Cleaner
This exact Resideo/Honeywell Home SKU is a complete cabinet with access door and MERV 13 media. FC200E1037 is the matching replacement filter, not the cabinet. Manufacturer reports 0.30 in. w.g. at 500 FPM and an equipment maximum of 2,000 CFM.
Score evidence: Research Index 75/100 underlies the public CabinetScore of 95/100 and reflects the published MERV, measured pressure at 500 FPM, included media, conservative six-month replacement interval, five-year warranty, service access and maximum flow rating. An HVAC installer must still verify the installed operating point.
Installed price: Obtain an exact quote for cabinet, media and any ductwork. No universal installed price is published.
A distinct F100 cabinet option with lower-grade MERV 11 media than the F200’s MERV 13. This complete 20 × 25 cabinet includes FC100A1037 media and an access door; it needs no electrical connection. Resideo publishes 0.23 in. w.c. at 500 FPM and a 2,000-CFM maximum. An installer must confirm duct fit and the actual blower operating point.
Score evidence: Research Index 73/100 maps to CabinetScore 92/100 with 100% weighted evidence coverage. The score uses the documented MERV, 500-FPM pressure, exact media, conservative six-month service guidance, warranty, access and maximum flow. This is not proof of better filtration than a MERV 13 cabinet.
Installed price: Obtain an exact dealer quote for the equipment, media and installation. No verified universal installed price is available.
A complete duct-mounted media-air-cleaner cabinet supplied with the current 3F213 TriPure MERV 13 filter. This replaces AprilAire's older 2210 cabinet, but the included new filter SKU must not be confused with the older 213 media.
MERV 1320 × 25 filter faceIncluded 3F2133-inch mediaUp to 12 months service10 years (terms apply) warranty
Score evidence: Manufacturer documents the media, replacement service, easy-glide access and cabinet warranty. A comparable exact-model pressure-drop measurement at 500 FPM was not located, so this criterion earns zero points and CabinetScore remains provisional.
Installed price: Obtain an exact quote for cabinet, media and any ductwork. No universal installed price is published.
Score details & evidenceResearch Index 70/100 · How the scale worksMissing data earns zero points: 30/100 underlying research points unavailable. This is not a measured performance failure.
A separate complete media cabinet designed for a 16 × 25 installation. Supplied with the current 3F413 TriPure MERV 13 filter and easy-glide rail. Replaces the older AprilAire 2410 configuration.
MERV 1316 × 25 filter faceIncluded 3F4133-inch mediaUp to 12 months service10 years (terms apply) warranty
Score evidence: Exact installed-media SKU, MERV, service and cabinet warranty are documented, but comparable absolute pressure-drop evidence at the same test velocity is not. The 16 × 25 fit is not automatically interchangeable with 20 × 25.
Installed price: Obtain an exact quote for cabinet, media and any ductwork. No universal installed price is published.
Score details & evidenceResearch Index 70/100 · How the scale worksMissing data earns zero points: 30/100 underlying research points unavailable. This is not a measured performance failure.
EDITORIAL PICK #5 · Powered electronic cabinet
AprilAire Model 5000 · Whole-House Electronic Air Purifier
This powered cabinet electrostatically enhances its Model 501 MERV 10 pleated media and uses the HVAC blower to move air. It is a different maintenance choice from passive media cabinets: disconnect power for servicing, replace media approximately annually and clean the internal components as the owner’s manual directs. Its full powered-system marketing comparison with MERV 15 does not make the included filter MERV 15 media.
Powered electronic cabinetModel 501 MERV 10 media16 × 25 nominal mediaApprox. annual media change5-year limited parts warranty
Score evidence: Research Index 55/100 maps to a provisional CabinetScore of 70/100 with 70% weighted evidence coverage. The documented media, annual interval, five-year limited parts warranty and service access earn points. Comparable pressure at 500 FPM and a verified maximum airflow remain missing and earn zero. Powered-system capture claims do not receive extra rubric points.
Installed price: Obtain an exact dealer quote for the equipment, media and installation. No verified universal installed price is available.
Score details & evidenceResearch Index 55/100 · How the scale worksMissing data earns zero points. The missing 30% is not redistributed; comparable 500-FPM pressure drop and a verified maximum airflow remain unconfirmed.
All five are complete installed HVAC air-cleaner cabinets. The AprilAire 5000 adds powered electronic components; the other four use passive media. Manufacturer images are linked to their source listings; the F100 family image is labelled illustrative. Affiliate commissions do not affect CabinetScore. F100 source review: October 26, 2026; Model 5000 evidence last reviewed October 25, 2026.
How this category is scored
CabinetScore is a separate 100-point rubric for complete duct-mounted air-cleaner cabinets. It is not the same as a portable purifier's CADR-based AirScore or a loose HVAC replacement filter's household-specific FilterScore.
25% Published included-media MERV rating
25% Measured pressure drop at the same 500-FPM face velocity
15% Exact replacement-media identification
10% Conservative filter service interval
10% Cabinet warranty
10% Published replacement-access design
5% Manufacturer maximum airflow rating, not a guaranteed operating flow
Evidence qualification requires at least 85% weighted coverage plus verified MERV, included replacement-media identity and comparable absolute pressure-drop data. Public CabinetScore uses a category-relative 100-point scale: the fixed 75-point Research Index reference maps to 95. Each card retains its underlying Research Index and evidence coverage. A high provisional score does not establish complete evidence or safe system fit. Incomplete cabinets receive a provisional CabinetScore. Missing criteria earn zero points, their weights are not redistributed, and evidence coverage is shown separately. A low provisional number can reflect missing documentation rather than poor measured performance.
Installation cost remains excluded from this cabinet rubric. A score does not establish blower, cabinet or duct compatibility; an installer must verify fit and static pressure. Read the scoring methodology.
The powered AprilAire 5000 is scored on the same documented cabinet and included-media criteria. Its Model 501 media is MERV 10; full-system electronic capture claims are not treated as a MERV 15 media rating and earn no additional points.
FilterTier only moves a system into a finalized ranked position when the exact model has enough verified evidence for the category. Marketing claims, peak-flow numbers and component certifications are not treated as equivalent to exact-system performance.
What to know before you buy
Have the HVAC system assessed
Ask the installer to document the proposed cabinet location, blower compatibility, pressure-drop assessment and filter-change access. These details should be part of the quote.
Understand when filtration happens
EPA explains that central filtration works when air is moving through the system. These cabinets depend on HVAC airflow. The AprilAire 5000 also needs electrical power for its electronic collection system; its electronics do not replace the HVAC blower.
Put the replacement code and instructions with the equipment records. Compare replacement media costs separately from installation. Follow the maker's service guidance rather than assuming a maximum interval is guaranteed.
Match the maintenance plan to the technology
Passive cabinets need correctly matched replacement media. The powered Model 5000 also requires disconnection of power and internal cleaning as its owner’s manual directs. Confirm filter access and any control or electrical work in the installer’s quote.
Frequently asked questions
Will a bigger cabinet automatically clean the air better?
No. Size alone does not establish compatibility, delivered airflow or the result in a home.
Can I compare these with a portable purifier's CADR?
Not as though they were the same equipment. Portable purifiers include a fan; these media cabinets operate within an HVAC system.
Do I need a complete cabinet if I already own one?
Does the county report select the right cabinet for me?
No. It provides outdoor context, not a duct inspection or a measurement of the home's airflow.
Is the AprilAire 5000 a MERV 15 filter?
Its included Model 501 pleated media is listed as MERV 10. The manufacturer’s MERV 15 comparison refers to the complete powered system under a different test method; it does not change the media’s MERV rating.
FilterTier provides independent comparison and educational information, not medical, plumbing, engineering or legal advice. Product claims, certifications, specifications, prices, warranties and availability can change; verify current details with the manufacturer and use water testing and a qualified professional when appropriate. Some outbound links may be affiliate/referral links, which may earn FilterTier compensation without changing the price you pay or the scoring methodology. Brand names, logos and product images belong to their respective owners.
Best Whole-House Air Purifiers: Ducted Options | FilterTierCompare five whole-house air cleaners: AprilAire U223, U243 and 5000 plus Honeywell F200 and F100, with exact media, installation guidance and CabinetScore.Best Whole-House Air Purifiers